THE TORONTO STAR Monday, October 26, 1998 A21
LETTERS
Be sure judges get right teachers
Sol Littman, Canadian director of the Simon Wiesenthal Centre (SWC), thinks that our "effort to
prosecute World War II criminals has been severely plagued by governmental callousness, lack
of experience and internal conflict" (Do our jurists need Holocaust classes? 0ct.20).
He may be right. Given the SWC's own strained ties to historical facts, though, his call for
sending judges "back to school" surprises.
In January, 1998, the SWC released a report entitled The Unwanted Guests: Swiss Forced Labor
Camps 1940-1944, accusing Switzerland of serious wartime crimes, and demanded compensation
for the victims.
The author, Alan Morris Schom � a U.S. historian and specialist in French colonial history, had
never even visited the Swiss federal archives and ignored the seminal work of André Lasserre.
Worse, a subsequent painstaking investigation by Australian businessman Ken Newman (who, as
Austrian Jew Kresimir Neumann had been one of the alleged victims), revealed that the overwhelming majority of the survivors reached not only contradicted Schom's account and expressed
gratitude for their wartime refuge, they had never been contacted by the SWC about any
compensation demands.
In June, 1998, Rabbi Marvin Hier presented the SWC's second hatchet job entitled Survey Of
Nazi And Pro-Nazi Groups In Switzerland 1930-1945.
The even more laughable allegations scraped together by Schom prompted Swiss Jewish leaders
to consider a class action suit for defamation against the SWC.
Nazi hunter Wiesenthal publicly distanced himself from the centre that carries his name.
Those associated with such shenanigans, perhaps, are poorly placed to teach history lessons.
Matthias Schlaepfer
Toronto
|