Home > 2011
| 2009 | 2001 | 1996 Files
Transcripts | 1999
Katriuk | Critiques
GoErie.com | 26Oct2011 | David Rising
AP Interview: Demjanjuk hopeful
of return home
Convicted of serving as a Nazi death camp guard and in failing health
at 91, John Demjanjuk still hopes he might be able to return home to
Ohio, his son says after seeing his father face-to-face for the first
time since his deportation in 2009.
In an interview with The Associated Press, John Demjanjuk Jr. said if a
court battle in Ohio results in his father being given permission by
Germany to return home, he would do so even before his appeal in
Germany is heard.
"Absolutely, immediately," Demjanjuk said after visiting with his
father for four days at his nursing home in the Bavarian town of Bad
Feilnbach. "We're Americans -- Americans of Ukrainian heritage -- and
that's his home."
Demjanjuk was found guilty in May on 28,060 counts of accessory to
murder after a Munich court found that evidence showed he was a guard
during the war the Nazis' Sobibor death camp in occupied Poland.
The case was the first time someone was convicted in Germany on the
basis only of having been a guard, without evidence of a specific
Ukrainian-born Demjanjuk was a Soviet Red Army soldier captured by the
Germans in Crimea in 1942.
The Munich court found that he agreed to serve the Nazis as a guard at
Sobibor. Demjanjuk has consistently rejected the allegation, insisting
he never served as a guard anywhere and was held in German camps
himself for much of World War II.
Demjanjuk was sentenced to five years in prison in Germany but released
pending appeal, which could take another year or more.
In releasing Demjanjuk, the court put no restrictions on his travel,
but he has no passport after being stripped of his U.S. citizenship
ahead of his deportation to Germany in 2009.
But his family is fighting in the U.S. They argue that the U.S.
government failed to disclose important evidence, namely a 1985 secret
FBI report uncovered by the AP. That report indicates the FBI believed
that a Nazi ID card purportedly showing that Demjanjuk served as a
death camp guard was a Soviet-made fake.
The family is attempting to reopen his U.S. citizenship case and hope
that even before there is a decision, the court will order that
Demjanjuk allowed back into the U.S.
That may seem unlikely, but it has already happened once before in the
approximately 35-year saga of Demjanjuk's legal battles.
In the 1980s, Demjanjuk stood trial in Israel accused of being the
notoriously brutal guard "Ivan the Terrible" at the Treblinka
extermination camp. He was convicted, sentenced to death -- then freed
when the Israeli Supreme Court overturned the ruling, saying the
evidence showed he was the victim of mistaken identity.
He then was allowed back to the U.S., and in a 1993 review of the
American denaturalization hearing that led to his extradition, a
federal U.S. appeals panel concluded that the Department of Justice's
Office of Special Investigations engaged in "prosecutorial misconduct
that seriously misled the court."
Demjanjuk Jr. said the family is now "very confident that we're going
to achieve a hearing before the Federal District court in Cleveland"
and also that his father's conviction in Germany will be overturned.
"We've been in this position before -- he was convicted and sentenced
death not in Germany, but in the state of Israel and on the face of it
on much more convincing evidence than Germany has ever seen -- and they
were wrong," he said.
"If the appellate court in Germany takes an honest approach like the
Israeli Supreme Court, it will be overturned -- I'm confident of that,"
he said. "The bigger question is if my father will live that long."
Demjanjuk Jr. said the nursing home care has been fine but his father
is isolated with nobody there speaking Ukrainian and only a few with
some English, though a Ukrainian priest visits about once a month.
"He's got a walker and he uses that -- as was the case before -- and
there are good days and bad days," he said. "All things considered, I
think he's doing OK, but he was certainly happy to see me -- it's
definitely a difficult situation for him, he's alone there."
It took another legal battle, however, to ensure Demjanjuk still
receives the medicine to treat his kidney disease, after Munich
authorities said they would no longer pay for it.
The Munich decision was based on a state doctor's assessment that
weekly shots of erythropoietin were unnecessary.
The family appealed the decision, and learned Tuesday that Munich city
authorities had decided to pay for the medication after all.
Demjanjuk Jr. said he and his father talked primarily about the family
and he shared photos of milestones that his father had missed, like
birthdays, sports events, and the high school graduation of a
granddaughter. He said his mother, 86, is in failing health herself and
was not able to visit.
For the most part, Demjanjuk Jr. said his father remains stoic about
his situation while steadfastly maintaining his innocence.
"He's not angry, that's the amazing thing ... he just deals with things
in front of him," he said. "He doesn't understand why he's in Germany
and blamed for the deeds of others, but he's a survivor."
Kyiv Post Comments:
Gerrit: 28Oct2011 at 13:28
Interestingly, Poland is going to reopen investigations into Auschwitz
crimes, and the Poles do not rule out that they will find Germans still
alive in Germany who participated in such crimes at Auschwitz-Birkenau
(and possibly at other camps in Poland), according to the Dutch
newspaper "De Telegraaf". The Poles were forced to abandon their
investigations in the 1980s due to many practical difficulties, but
these difficulties have, of course, disappeared with the fall of the Iron
If the Poles do find such people, they will formally charge them --
something the German government clearly does not want to do, and has not
done for the past 60-odd years.
Be interesting to see how the German government tries to worm its way out of THIS one........
Guest: 27Oct2011 at 15:57
And Germany and the USA have the nerve to lecture Ukraine about fair trials and rule of law.
Gerrit: 27Oct2011 at 11:57
The Bundes Kriminal Amt (BKA) recognized that the so-called identity
card was a KGB fake years ago -- yet it is STILL being used as "proof" of
Demjanjuk's guilt. In the latest trial, it was the only "evidence" that
existed -- no witness declarations or ANY other legal evidence. The Court
"assumed" that Demjanjuk would have actively participated in the mass
murder, which undoubtedly DID take place -- but since when is "assumption"
proof of guilt????
The late professor Wagenaar of the Netherlands also tore the "evidence"
to shreds, so one can only conclude that the Demjanjuk prosecution is
purely for political reasons -- Germany, after ignoring its own guilty
citizens for decades, suddenly decides it wants to look good, and starts
prosecuting a few remaining foreigners who MIGHT have participated in a
very minor role, at the same time portraying these people as
"Eichmann's most important accomplices."
Guest: 27Oct2011 at 10:17
While I do not want this comment read as any judgement of guilt or
innocence of the person involved it is Obvious that "political" trials
guilty or not can occur anywhere; this one took place in countries (US
& Europe) who do not hesitate to lecture others!
Guilty of Genocide for maybe watching: 27Oct2011 at 09:37
If Demjanjuk is Guilty of Genocide for maybe being a guard and maybe
watching the Holocaust, then what kind of risk are the rest of us at for
being actual viewers of Holocaust movies and documentaries with no
"maybe' about it???
Global Political Show farce: 27Oct2011 at 09:27
All of these TRIALS were a blatant farce and mockery of ANY sort of
Justice...they were pure political SHOW trials worthy of STALIN! Those
who pushed , coerced and manipulated these trials should be put on trial
themselves! (The behind the scenes lobby terrorist cabals and their
front OSI tax payer supported apparatus!)